We’re taking a look at how fans have rated A Day To Remember’s discography, with user scores from Rate Your Music ranking every album from highest to lowest!
Topping the list is Homesick (2009) with a 3.30 rating.
Common Courtesy (2013) follows with 3.26.
For Those Who Have Heart (2007) lands next with 3.21.
What Separates Me From You (2010) comes in just behind with 3.16.
Old Record (2008) sits at 2.89.
Bad Vibrations (2016) follows with 2.81.
And Their Name Was Treason (2005) comes in at 2.72.
Big Ole Album Vol. 1 (2025) lands just behind with 2.70.
You’re Welcome (2021) rounds out the list with 1.63.
The rankings are based entirely on user ratings, giving a snapshot of how fans are viewing the band’s catalogue right now. While some placements feel expected, others might raise a few eyebrows, especially with how close some of the scores are.
