We’re taking a look at a fan driven ranking of Neck Deep’s discography, with users on Rate Your Music scoring every album from highest to lowest.
The rankings are based on user ratings, meaning they reflect fan opinion rather than critics or chart performance. Even so, it lines up pretty closely with how a lot of the scene talks about Neck Deep’s catalogue, especially with Life’s Not Out to Get You still widely seen as their defining record nearly a decade on.
Life’s Not Out to Get You – 2015 with a 3.58/5.00 rating
The Peace and the Panic – 2017 follows in second with 3.14/5.00
Wishful Thinking – 2014 lands in third with 3.06/5.00
Neck Deep – 2024 album comes next with 3.05/5.00
All Distortions Are Intentional – 2020 rounds out the list with 2.63/5.00
With the band still active and putting out new music, it’s the kind of ranking that’s only going to keep shifting over time. But for now, it’s a solid snapshot of how fans are viewing their discography in 2026.
